359
Productivity & Workflow355
Software Development249
Automation & Workflow238
Marketing & Growth207
AI Infrastructure & MLOps197
Photography & Imaging169
Writing & Content Creation195
Design & Creative172
Data & Analytics165
Customer Support157
Education & Learning144
Sales & Outreach133
Voice & Speech128
Operations & Admin119
Thomas Nagel won the $1 million Berggruen Prize. In a Wired interview, he argued chatbots are not conscious and warned people may still believe they are.
In short: Philosopher Thomas Nagel won the $1 million Berggruen Prize and said it is “ridiculous” to think today’s chatbots are conscious.
Thomas Nagel, an 89-year-old philosopher and professor emeritus at New York University, won this week’s $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy and Culture. The award recognizes thinkers whose ideas shape how people understand themselves and society.
Nagel is best known for his 1974 essay “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?”, which asks what consciousness feels like from the inside. In a new interview with Wired, Nagel said the rise of large language models, meaning AI systems trained on huge amounts of text to predict and produce sentences, has not changed his view that these systems are not conscious.
Nagel criticized a common idea in philosophy called functionalism. In simple terms, functionalism suggests that if something acts like a mind, it could be a mind, no matter what it is made of (like saying any device that plays music counts as a “radio,” whether it uses tubes or circuits). Nagel disagreed, arguing that the physical “stuff” matters, and that data centers and computer chips are nothing like nervous systems in living organisms.
He also warned that chatbots can be trained to talk about “their feelings” in convincing ways, even if there is no inner experience behind the words. He said this could lead many people to believe the systems are conscious, which he sees as dangerous, especially when companies have financial reasons to make their products seem lifelike.
As chatbots become more common in schools, workplaces, and personal life, people may treat them like beings with feelings and rights. Nagel argues that getting this wrong could confuse moral decisions, like whether we owe a machine care, or whether it is only a tool.
Source: Wired